Your destination for insight into the world of event fundraising and charity auctions.

Amplify Event Revenue by Selling Auction Packages Multiple Times

Posted by Ian Lauth

Charity Auction Packages

One of the most advantageous parts of using consignment items in a charity auction is the ability to sell them to more than one bidder. This simple strategy, when utilized correctly, can quickly amplify the amount your organization makes on a single auction item.

At Nonprofit auction events, friendly bidding wars among guests result in more money raised for charity. Plus, everyone likes to be part of an active auction. When bidders compete over a single item, however, that usually only means one winner per item. With certain consignment items, such as auction travel packages, it can be a different story completely. Instead of only selling to the highest bidder, you can sell a single item multiple times and double, triple or even quadruple the amount you raise from the auction.

Consider the following example:
A travel auction package has a Nonprofit cost of $2,200 with a target sale price of $2,6400 (20% over cost)...

Nonprofit Travel Packages


The top three bidders submit bids at $3,300, $3,400 and $3,500. If you sell the package to the top bidder, you net $1,300 - which is great! But if you reduce the price to $3,300 (the lowest of the top three bids) and sell it to all three top bidders, you will net $3,300 - almost tripling the amount raised on a single package!

So how can your Nonprofit set the stage for successfully selling auction trip packages multiple times during a fundraising auction? Consider these tips:

1. Find the right consignment company

Work with a reputable consignment company that offers clients the ability to sell auction packages more than once. Every Winspire Experience, for example, can be sold to more than one bidder, often with no limit. 

Read Next: "Consignment Travel Is for Suckers: Letter from a Skeptic"

2. Know and understand the reserve price

A reserve price is a hidden minimum price—essentially, the lowest price you're willing to accept for an auction item. Big-ticket consignment packages come with a base price for Nonprofits. This is what it costs the charity to claim the prize. Understanding this cost and setting the appropriate reserve price at the auction will help ensure you price the package accordingly to encourage bidding and maximize your profit. We usually recommend setting a reserve of 20% or more over the Nonprofit cost.

3. Keep it a secret

Don’t tell your guests that more than one auction package is available, because you want bidders to drive the price up. Instead, wait until the end when the winner is determined and then ask the next top bidders if they would also be interested in the package at the last price bid.

Here's how it's done...

Live Auction

Encourage excitement and active bidding on big-ticket items like Winspire Travel Packages. If bidding is getting close to the reserve price and you still have a handful of people bidding, pay close attention. If you surpass the reserve price and you still have two or three people engaged in a bidding war, this is the perfect time to leverage multiple sales of a single package.

If the third bidder drops out but the two bidders who are left are really fighting for the win, let them continue bidding. Wait until the last bidder drops out and then offer the package to the top two bidders. If, like in our example before, bidding only went up $200 to $300 past the point where the third bidder dropped out, reduce the price to what the third bidder's last bid was and offer it to all three. The top two winning bidders will happily pay a reduced price, and all three will be excited to win the package.

Silent Auction

Boost silent auction involvement through enthusiastic conversation with guests and regular announcements about when the auction closes. When it's time to conclude and close out the silent auction, check the top two or three bidders on the bid sheet before announcing the winning person.

If the next two bidders are within several hundred dollars from the top bid, quietly find those two bidders and see if they are willing to pay the lower bid. Then find the winning bidder and tell them they won - but at a reduced price! More people will have the opportunity to claim the prize and the charity gets to raise more money, making it a win-win!

Luxury Properties for Silent Auction Tables

Post-event Fundraising

There will be times when some of your best donors have other commitments and cannot attend the event. If you have donors who you know would be interested in a package but can't be at the event, follow up afterward and offer them the package at the winning bidder's price. Some donors may jump at the opportunity and you'll get to raise more funds yet again.

Alternatively, if there was a lot of interest in a particular package at the event, you can open it up to the entire guest list. Simply send an email newsletter after the event explaining the expanded availability of the package, allowing all attendees the opportunity to purchase it at the winning price. Just make sure you don't undercut your winning bidder by offering it for less - you want everyone to feel good about their donations and prizes.

Do you have any strategies that you've used to double, triple or quadruple your money with consignment packages that can be sold multiple times? We want to hear about them! Leave a comment or email so we can share them!

Check out our catalog of over 200 unique Experiences for your auction.

Fundraising, Selling Multiples, Consignment
Ian Lauth
Ian Lauth
With an extensive background in marketing development and content design, Ian’s role at Winspire is to develop external communications, brand expansion and product delivery processes to help Nonprofits maximize their fundraising revenue. Ian serves as the Editor-in-Chief for Winspire News, creating and managing blog content, newsletters, eBooks and other resources for Nonprofit fundraising professionals.

Related Posts

Silent Auction Bid Sheets: How to Get Started [+ Template]

When your nonprofit hosts a silent auction, the items are the star of the show. After all, you’ll only hit your fundraising goal by motivating supporters to bid on your high-value prizes! To encourage competitive bidding, showcasing your items in an appealing way is essential, and one way to do this is through well-designed bid sheets. Although bid sheets are primarily a tool to track which auction participants are vying for which items, they can also grab supporters’ attention and provide them with key information to help them decide if and how much to bid on a particular prize.

  • 14 min read
  • Sep 1, 2023 8:23:36 AM

20+ Exciting Raffle Basket Ideas for Nonprofit Fundraisers

Raffles are some of the most engaging and fun fundraisers out there. The chance of winning an appealing grand prize combined with the ability to support a good cause often attracts a wide audience, allowing your nonprofit to bring in significant fundraising revenue. Plus, they’re fairly simple to organize and can be paired with many other events and campaigns.

  • 16 min read
  • Sep 1, 2023 7:51:09 AM

Design Your Own Charity Auction Catalog [+ Template]

If your nonprofit is hosting an auction fundraising event, it’s important to consider how to get participants excited about bidding on your most valuable auction items. Designing a charity auction catalog will help you do just that!